• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Yellow Bricks

by Duncan Epping

  • Home
  • Unexplored Territory Podcast
  • HA Deepdive
  • ESXTOP
  • Stickers/Shirts
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Show Search
Hide Search

vSAN

What do I do after a vSAN Stretched Cluster Site Takeover?

Duncan Epping · Nov 10, 2025 · 4 Comments

Over the last couple of months, various new vSAN features were announced. Two of those features are around the Stretched Cluster configuration, and have probably been the number 1 feature request for a few years. Now that we have Site Takeover and Site Maintenance functionality available, I am starting to get some questions about the impact of them, and in particular, the Site Takeover functionality is raising some questions.

For those who don’t know what these features are, let me describe them briefly:

Site Maintenance = The ability to place a full vSAN stretched cluster Fault Domain into maintenance mode at once. This ensures that all hosts within the fault domain have consistently stored the data, and all hosts will go into maintenance mode at the same time.

Site Takeover = This provides the ability when a Witness and a Data Site has failed to bring back the remaining site through a command line interface. This will reconstruct the remaining “site local” RAID configuration, making the objects available again, which will then allow vSphere HA to restart the VMs.

Now, the question that the above typically raises is what happens to the Witness and the Data Site that failed when you do the Site Takeover? If you look at the VMs RAID configuration, you will notice that both the Witness and the Data Site components of the sites that failed will completely disappear from the RAID configuration.

But what do you do next, because even after you run the Site Takeover, you still see your hosts and the witness in vCenter Server, and you still see a stretched cluster configuration in the UI. Now at first I thought that if the environment was completely up and running again, you had to go through some manual effort to reconstruct the stretched cluster. Basically, remove the failed hosts, wipe the disks, and recreate the stretched cluster. This is, however, not the case.

In the example above, if the Preferred site and the Witness site return for duty, vSAN will automatically discard the stale components in those previously failed sites. It will recreate new components for all objects, and it will do a full resync of the data.

If you end up in a situation where your hosts are completely gone (let’s say as a result of a fire), then you will have to do some kind of manual cleanup as follows, before you rebuild and add hosts back:

  • Remove the failed hosts from the vCenter inventory
  • Remove the witness from the vCenter inventory
    • Delete the witness from the vCenter Server it is running, a real delete!
  • Delete the surviving Fault Domain, this should be the only Fault Domain still listed in the vCenter interface
  • You now have a normal cluster again
  • Rebuild hosts and recreate the stretched cluster

I hope that helps,

vSAN Stretched Cluster vs Fault Domains in a “campus” setting?

Duncan Epping · Sep 25, 2025 · 2 Comments

I got this question internally recently: Should we create a vSAN Stretched Cluster configuration or create a vSAN Fault Domains configuration when we have multiple datacenters within close proximity on our campus? In this case, we are talking about less than 1ms latency RTT between buildings, maybe a few hundred meters at most. I think it is a very valid question, and I guess it kind of depends on what you are looking to get out of the infrastructure. I wrote down the pros and cons, and wanted to share those with the rest of the world as well, as it may be useful for some of you out there. If anyone has additional pros and cons, feel free to share those in the comments!

vSAN Stretched Clusters:

  • Pro: You can replicate across fault domains AND protect additionally within a fault domain with R1/R5/R6 if required.
  • Pro: You can decide whether VMs should be stretched across Fault Domains or not, or just protected within a fault domain/site
  • Pro: Requires less than 5MS RTT latency, which is easily achievable in this scenario
  • Con/pro: you probably also need to think about DRS/HA groups (VM-to-Host)
  • Con: From an operational perspective, it also introduces a witness host, and sites, which may complicate things, and at the various least requires a bit more thinking
  • Con: Witness needs to be hosted somewhere
  • Con: Limited to 3 Fault Domains (2x data + 1x witness)
  • Con: Limited to 20+20+1 configuration

vSAN Fault Domains:

  • Pro: No real considerations around VM-to-host rules usually, although you can still use it to ensure certain VMs are spread across buildings
  • Pro: No Witness Appliance to manage, update or upgrade. No overhead of running a witness somewhere
  • Pro: No design considerations around “dedicated” witness sites and “data site”, each site has the same function
  • Pro: Can also be used with more than 3 Fault Domains or Datacenters, so could even be 6 Fault Domains, for instance
  • Pro: Theoretically can go up to 64 hosts
  • Con: No ability to protect additionally within a fault domain
  • Con: No ability to specify that you don’t want to replicate VMs across Fault Domains
  • Con/Pro: Requires sub-1ms RTT latency at all times, which is low, but will be achievable in a campus cluster, usually

#100 – What is the Google Cloud VMware Engine all about? Featuring Sai Gopalan and Ken Bocchino

Duncan Epping · Jul 21, 2025 · Leave a Comment

Episode 100, YESSSS! Finally, we managed to get there. For this episode, I invited two Google Cloud VMware Engine (GCVE) product managers to explain what GCVE is all about. We had Dr. Wade Holmes on the show, 84 episodes ago, to introduce GCVE, so it was time to re-introduce GCVE and discuss the current solution, and the benefits it brings with for instance the flexibility in node types, bring your own licensing, disaster recovery, networking, and much more. Ken and Sai had some interesting stories, so make sure to pay close attention! Listen via the embedded player below, or simply go to your favorite podcast player and find the episode there! (Spotify, Apple)

Where is the vSAN Snapmanager Appliance with 9.0?

Duncan Epping · Jul 7, 2025 · 4 Comments

I was talking to my colleague Paudie and he mentioned various folks were having problems finding the vSAN Snapmanager Appliance for vSAN / VCF / vSphere 9.0. The appliance used to be stored on the Broadcom Support portal under VMware vSAN >> Drivers & Tools, but it is no longer there.

This is not by mistake. Some may have heard about this, others may have skipped over it, but VMware Live Recovery, vSphere Replication, and vSAN Data Protection (which includes the Snapmanager Appliance) have all converged into a single appliance to make your life easier! This means that if you want to enable vSAN Data Protection, you now need to download the VMware Live Recovery Appliance, specifically version 9.0.3.0 or later.

Where is the vSAN Snapmanager Appliance with 9.0?

My favorite VMware Explore 2025 sessions!

Duncan Epping · Jul 3, 2025 · Leave a Comment

Yes, it is that time of the year again… VMware Explore season! As I write this, I am in the middle of developing the content for Explore, as I have two sessions approved myself. I created a so-called targeted agenda, so if you want to attend any of the below sessions, just go here.

The two sessions I am presenting can be found here. But for those who don’t want to click, they are:

  • Three Times the Performance, Half the Latency: VMware vSAN Express Storage Architecture Deep Dive for VMware Geeks [CLOB1067LV] Featuring Pete Koehler and Duncan Epping
  • Six Innovations Redefining Storage and Disaster Recovery for VMware Cloud Foundation [CLOB1028LV] Featuring Rakesh Radhakrishnan and Duncan Epping

If you are attending Explore, and are planning on attending those sessions, make sure to register as soon as you can as they were “sold out” in previous years!

Now, for the rest of the content catalog, these are the sessions I hope to be able to attend:

  • Deploying Minimal VMware Cloud Foundation 9.0 Lab [CLOB1201LV] hosted by Alan Renouf and William Lam
  • The Isolated Clean Room Blueprint for On-Premises Based Cyber Recoveries [CLOB1267LV] hosted by Michael McLaughlin
  • A Deep Dive into Memory Tiering with NVMe [CLOB1122LV] hosted by Dave Morera
  • Bridging the Gap: Managing Virtual Machines in a Kubernetes World [CLOB1938LV] hosted by Kat Brookfield
  • Design and Architect: Multi-cluster Management for Kubernetes at Scale with VMware Cloud Foundation 9.0 [CLOB1471LV] hosted by Kris Inglis and Hugo Phan
  • 10 Amazing New Things with VMware Live Recovery [CLOB1943LV] hosted by Jatin Jindal and Nabil Quadri
  • Building Secure Private AI Deep Dive [INVB1432LV] hosted by Chris McCain
  • 5 Key Capabilities of Next-Gen Data Protection and Ransomware Recovery with vSAN for All VCF Workloads [CLOB1265LV] hosted by Rakesh Radhakrishnan and Sazzala Reddy
  • Design and Architect: Best Practices for Deploying VMware Cloud Foundation 9.0 [CLOB1427LV] hosted by Prak Kalra and Sushil Suvarna
  • Design and Architect: Managing and Operating at Scale with VCF 9.0 [CLOB1487LV] hosted by Ivaylo Ivanov and Michael Kolos
  • Real-World Lessons in Rightsizing VMware Cloud Foundation for On-Premises AI Workloads [INVB1300LV] hosted by Frank Denneman and Johan van Amersfoort

If you feel that a session is missing, feel free to leave a comment!

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Page 4
  • Page 5
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 71
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

About the Author

Duncan Epping is a Chief Technologist and Distinguished Engineering Architect at Broadcom. Besides writing on Yellow-Bricks, Duncan is the co-author of the vSAN Deep Dive and the vSphere Clustering Deep Dive book series. Duncan is also the host of the Unexplored Territory Podcast.

Follow Us

  • X
  • Spotify
  • RSS Feed
  • LinkedIn

Recommended Book(s)

Also visit!

For the Dutch-speaking audience, make sure to visit RunNerd.nl to follow my running adventure, read shoe/gear/race reviews, and more!

Do you like Hardcore-Punk music? Follow my Spotify Playlist!

Do you like 80s music? I got you covered!

Copyright Yellow-Bricks.com © 2026 ยท Log in