Yellow Bricks

by Duncan Epping

vsan esa

#094 – Discussing SAP HANA support for vSAN ESA 8.x with Erik Rieger!

· · Leave a Comment

Recently Broadcom announced that ⁠vSAN ESA support for SAP HANA was introduced⁠. Erik Rieger is Broadcom’s Principal SAP Global Technical Alliance Manager and Architect, and as such I invited him on the show to go over what this actually means, and why this is important for customers! Listen to the episode on Apple (https://bit.ly/42AKWze), Spotify (https://bit.ly/4j1Jo7r), via the player below, or your favorite podcast app. Make sure to like and subscribe wherever possible!

For more details, make sure to check:

Does vSAN Data Protection work with vSAN Stretched Clusters and can snapshots be stretched?

· · Leave a Comment

I have written a few articles about vSAN Data Protection now, and my last article featured a nice vSAN DP demo. A very good question was asked in the comment section, and it was about vSAN Stretched Clusters. Basically, the question was whether Snapshots are also stretched across locations. This is a great question, as there are a couple of things which are probably worth explaining again.

vSAN Data Protection relies on the snapshot capability which was introduced with vSAN ESA. This snapshot capability in vSAN ESA is significantly different than with vSAN OSA or with VMFS. With vSAN OSA and VMFS when you create a snapshot a new object (vSAN) or file (VMFS) is created. With vSAN ESA this is no longer the case as we don’t create additional files or objects, but we create a copy of the metadata structure instead. This is why vSAN ESA snapshots perform much better than vSAN OSA or VMFS snapshots do, as we no longer need to traverse multiple files or objects to read data. We can simply use the same object, and leverage the metadata structure to keep track of what has changed.

Now, with vSAN, as most of you hopefully know, object (and it’s components) are placed across the cluster based on what is specified within the storage policy that is associated with the object or VM. In other words, if the policy states FTT=1 and RAID-1, then you will see 2 copies of the data. If the policy states the data needs to be stretched across locations, and within each location be protected with RAID-5, then you will see a RAID-1 configuration across sites and a RAID-5 configuration within each site. As vSAN ESA snapshots are an integral part of the object, the snapshots automatically follow all requirements as defined within the policy. In other words, if the policy says stretched then the snapshot will also automatically be stretched.

There is one caveat I want to call out, and for that I want to show a diagram. The diagram below shows the Data Protection Appliance, aka the snapshot manager appliance. As you can see, it states “metadata decoupled from appliance” and it links somehow to a global namespace object. This global namespace object is where all the details of the protected VMs (and more) is being stored. As you can imagine, both the Snapshot Manager, as well as the Global Namespace object should also be stretched. For the global namespace object this means that you need to ensure that the default datastore policy is set to “stretched”, and of course for the snapshot manager appliance you can simply select the correct policy when provisioning the appliance. Either way, make sure the default datastore policy aligns with the disaster recovery and data protection policy.

Does vSAN Data Protection work with vSAN Stretched Clusters and can snapshots be stretched?

I hope this helps those exploring vSAN Data Protection in a stretched cluster configuration!

Scalable Snapshots demo with the vSAN 8.0 Express Storage Architecture

· ·

Starting with vSAN 8 a brand new architecture was introduced called “Express Storage Architecture”. Over the last year or so a lot of information has been shared about ESA and the benefits of ESA. One of the things which ESA introduces is much-improved snapshot scalability.

With vSAN OSA, and with VMFS, when you create a snapshot you typically immediately see a performance degradation. This is because both VMFS and vSAN OSA still operate using the redo-log based snapshot mechanism. This means that with vSAN OSA when you create a snapshot a new object is created and writes are re-directed. It also means that reads will be coming from various files, if you have one or more snapshots. This mechanism is, unfortunately, not very effective. Let me borrow a diagram that is part of a post John Nicholson wrote to demonstrate that old logic.

With vSAN 8 ESA the mechanism has changed and no longer does vSAN, or vSphere for that matter, create an additional object. vSAN ESA handles this on a meta-data level. In other words, instead of redirecting writes and traversing files for reads, vSAN now leverages a highly efficient B-Tree structure and pointers to keep track of which block is associated with which snapshot.

Not only is this more efficient from a capacity perspective, but more importantly it is very efficient from a performance standpoint. I ran half a dozen tests in my lab, and what I saw was a below 2% performance impact between a VM without a snapshot and a VM with one or multiple snapshots. I could NOT see a significant difference between the first or the fifth snapshot. I do want to point out that my lab is not officially certified to run vSAN ESA, nevertheless, I was very impressed with the results.

During the last run, I actually recorded the whole exercise. In this demo, I show the creation of one snapshot, while the VM is running a benchmark (HCIBench). Now, during the testing, I created not one but various snapshots and of course, I deleted all of them as well. You have all probably experienced extensive stun times during the deletion of a snapshot at times, and this is where vSAN ESA shines. The stun times have been reduced by 100 times, and that is something I am sure each of you will appreciate. Why have they been reduced drastically? Well, simply because we no longer have to copy data from one vSAN object to another. This makes a huge difference, not just for stun times, but also for performance in general (latency, IOPS, throughput). If you are interested, have a look at the demo!

MAXimizing vSAN’s potential with the Express Storage Architecture (vSAN Max)

· ·

Last week at VMware Explore a few vSAN features and offerings were announced, one of them being vSAN Max! All week I have been having conversations with customers who were highly excited about the new solution. For those who did not read the announcements, or listened to the Unexplored Territory Podcast episode on the topic, let me go over what was announced and what vSAN Max is.

As most of you know, vSAN is a hyperconverged storage platform delivered via VMware’s flagship product vSphere. This means that if you have vSphere running, vSAN is literally two clicks away from being enabled. You will need local storage devices, and those local devices then will be formed into a shared datastore on top of which you can run your VMs. Although HCI solutions work for most customers, at certain levels of scale it may be preferred to have a disaggregated solution and share a dedicated storage platform with one or multiple vSphere clusters. This is what vSAN Max brings to the table.

Looking at the above diagram a few things stand out when it comes to vSAN Max. First of all, it says “Storage Only” and secondly it mentions “Supports high-density ESA ReadyNodes”. There are a few things to unwrap here. Firstly, vSAN Max is based on vSAN Express Storage Architecture, aka vSAN ESA. This means that it is a single tier of storage, based on NVMe flash devices. On top of that, it also means that all available data services will also be available on vSAN Max: Fault Domains, Stretched Clustering, vSAN File Services, iSCSI, Compression, Encryption etc. All of these are also included by default in the license by the way, it is just a single edition from a licensing point of view and it will include vSphere. In other words, vSphere + vSAN Enterprise by default, and licensed on capacity instead of CPU/Cores.

Secondly, it mentions “high-density”, vSAN Max starts at 200TB per host, and has a minimum of 6 hosts per cluster. This means that the starting capacity is 1.2 Petabytes for a vSAN Max cluster. The maximum number of hosts within a cluster is 32 at the time of writing (but 24 hosts being the recommended maximum), and it will support up to 8.6 Petabytes and around 3.4 million IOPS.

It also mentions ReadyNodes, and let me stress this, ReadyNodes! We still see a lot of customers picking random components for their vSAN cluster and then being surprised that Skyline Health reports the cluster is not supported. For vSAN Max there will be a separate set of vSAN ReadyNode configurations. These configurations will have for instance 100Gbps network cards, and as mentioned a minimum of 200TB per host.

Now, this doesn’t mean that the connecting clusters need to be running 100GbE, they can be even 1Gbps connected, that’s up to you and the requirements you have from a performance perspective. The 100GbE connections will be used for intra-cluster communications, so the switching architecture also needs to cater to this.

Knowing all of this, you may wonder what the use cases are for vSAN Max. As Pete Koehler mentioned, it can be used for anything, but is primarily targeted at those with high capacity requirements and who prefer a centralized model, but still want to manage their storage platform through vCenter Server and use all the bells and whistles that come with it (and with VROps for instance).

Hopefully, that provides some insights in terms of what to expect when vSAN Max goes “general availability” I will follow up with some short demos showing what it will look like, although that will probably be relatively boring as it will look very similar to vSAN ESA. In the meanwhile, there’s a bunch of material on the VMware website that you can check out.

New book: VMware vSAN 8.0 U1 Express Storage Architecture Deep Dive!

· ·

We already gave some hints on twitter, and during an episode of the Unexplored Territory podcast, but here it finally is… The new book, the VMware vSAN 8.0 U1 Express Storage Architecture Deep Dive! It has been a year since we released the vSAN 7.0 U3 Deep Dive book, and with this brand new vSAN architecture being introduced in vSAN 8.0 we figured it was time to do a full overhaul of the book as well. Mind you, this new book purely deals with the Express Storage Architecture, aka vSAN ESA. This also means that some of the features which are not supported by ESA are not discussed in this book, for that you will need to buy the vSAN 7.0 U3 Deep Dive book, which covers OSA. Another big change is that we brought in a third author, we asked our good friend Pete Koehler to contribute to the book. Pete had done reviews of previous books, and considering the amount of material he produced for VMware Tech Marketing for vSAN (and ESA specifically) it made a lot of sense to bring him in!

VMware’s vSAN has rapidly proven itself in environments ranging from hospitals to oil rigs to e-commerce platforms and is the market leader in the hyperconverged space. Along the way, the world of IT has rapidly changed, not just from a software point of view, but also from a hardware perspective. With vSAN 8.0 VMware brought a new architecture to market called vSAN Express Storage Architecture (ESA). This architecture is highly optimized for today’s world of datacenter resources, be it CPU, memory, networking, or NVMe based flash storage.

The authors of the vSAN Deep Dive have thoroughly updated their definitive guide to this transformative technology. Writing for vSphere administrators, architects, and consultants, Cormac Hogan, Duncan Epping , and Pete Koehler explain what vSAN ESA is, why the architecture has changed, what it now offers, and how to gain maximum value from it. The book offers expert insight into preparation, installation, configuration, policies, provisioning, clusters, architecture, and more. You’ll also find practical guidance for using all data services, stretched clusters, two-node configurations, and cloud-native storage services.

Although we pressed publish on Tuesday, sometimes it takes a while before the book is available in all Amazon stores, but it should just trickle down in the upcoming 24-48 hours. The book is priced at 9.99 USD for the ebook and 29.99 USD for a paper copy, and is sold through Amazon only. Get it while it is hot, and we would appreciate it if you would use our referral links and leave a review when you finish it. Thanks for the support, and we hope you will enjoy it!

Of course, we also have the links to other major Amazon stores: